The English
language now came to a point in which it started being controversial. Not only
was it the dominating language in several parts of the world, but it was the
language in which many publications were written in. Moreover, it was the main
way in which knowledge was transferred. Among the main thinkers of the
seventeenth and eighteenth centuries was John Locke. He stated, “If the
definition of words could be agreed and misunderstandings avoided, peace would
follow” (The Adventure of English). I
agree with Locke in the sense that most misunderstandings occur because of the
different use of the same language. If people are able to understand one
another, they will probably work their differences out and stay out of conflict.
Newton introduced several terms that were used to describe scientific
investigations. I believe that this refining of the English language was essential
so scientific concepts could be transmitted accurately and precisely. Newton
redefined English for his benefit, but it really was a benefit for all.
Jonathan Swift hated the “vulgar
liberties” that individuals were taking with the English language. I found it
surprising to see that the critics to the English language began centuties ago
and are not a new thing. I agree with Swift in the sense that English should be
standardized and should have clear gramatical rules. This is essential for its
well-functioning. Samuel Johnson created one of the most famous dictionary.
However, one of his major flaws was that he did not include words that he did
not understand or that related to science. I disagree with him in this aspect,
since these words are essential for certain knowledge to be expressed
appropiately. Austen had a very particular viwe of the English language, since
she thought of it as a way to judge one’s social status and determine his
social acceptability. I found this very interesting since it represents another
way, besides knowledge, in which the English language was being used. This
greatly influenced social life at the time. Another great thinker of the era,
Thomas Paine, believed that “simpler language could carry precise thought” (The Adventure of English). This is
completely true. I belive that the more complex a language gets, the more it
can express, but thee fewer it can be understood. William Wordsworth agreed
with Paine in this aspect, since he thought that special poetic diction was not
needed for a message to be transmitted. So long as the individual understood what
is said, nothing else is needed. Finally, William Cobbet summarizes the
importance of English in daily life. Without English, one will not be able to
acquire sufficient knowledge to progress in life.
Some of the problems with the
theories deal with the fact that the English language is and will continue to
change. English will not remain static and will continue a process of evolution
that does not allow English to be completely standardized. In addition, English
will differ depending on the región it is spoken in. Therefore, several
dialects will begin branching off the language and keep creting
misunderstandings and several slangs. The thinkers’ logical thinking Works only
for their present, not necessarily for the future of the language. In the
present, we continue to view language as the main way to acquire knowledge.
However, we view our language as a manner of communicating and being able come
to agreements. Each one views their language differently depending on how it
was taught to them and how they use it.
The Adventure of English. Dir. Nigel Wattis. Perf. Amanda Root and David Gwillim. LWT, 2003. Youtube. 19 Sept. 2011. Web. 22 Jan. 2013.
No hay comentarios:
Publicar un comentario